Mario Kart PC Forum - Advanced search
Results 21-40 out of 180+
Rating your Retro Tracks.
8028 pts ★ Expert
5000 pts ★ NoviceOn 2026-07-06 at 23:15:09
Gameplay 32/35. Overall, the track plays good, it’s got some fun gimmicks, I really like the trick able bumps in the moon
Visual 22/25. It looks good overall, but some parts are blurry. The fact that you added more unique sections visually boosted the score here.
Is it a faithful recreation OR does it add to the original 28/30 This is a great rendition of SNES Rainbow Road, I like the fact that you added new sections to make the track interesting. I do kinda wish that the thwomps were a different color, it would be more accurate if they were rainbow
Miscellaneous 9/10 The general aspects are really good, but not perfect.
Final score: 91/100 A
N64 Koopa Troopa Beach - https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=194471
Gameplay 31/35. I think it’s just my monkey brain, but I just like doing all the tricks on the ramps.
Visual 19/25. I’m not a huge fan of the style, but the colors are nice.
Is it a faithful recreation OR does it add to the original 26/30 This is a good recreation of the original n64 version, (the better one) I think it would be interesting if there were rising tides that allow for you to occasionally take a tighter line.
miscellaneous 9/10 The music is good
Final score: 85/100 B
Both of these were solid tracks.
1
1
1On 2026-07-06 at 02:56:18
Hello. I’m noticed a lot of people making topics like this, where they rate others tracks. So I figured that I’d make one exclusively for retro tracks.
This is simple, you send me retro tracks and I rate them using a system.
Here are the factors that I will grade on:
Gameplay _/35. This is just does the track play well.
Visual _/25. Does the track look good and fit a style. (Also is the image original and not stolen).
Is it a faithful recreation OR does it add to the original _/30 This depends on if the track is meant to replicate the original, or reimagine it. Depending on which one it is, you will either be graded on how faithful of a recreation it is, or how much it adds to the original while still being the track.
Miscellaneous _/10 This is just general stuff. For example, backgrounds, music, readability.
This leads to a general rating system out of a 100. With the following grading system.
S (99-100)
A (90-98 )
B(80-89)
C(70-79)
D(60-69)
F(0-59)
There are also rules because people always break obvious rules when I fail to establish them.
Rule 1: Must be a retro. The track must be a retro of an official nintendo track, no recreations from other racing games or a remake of your nitros.
Rule 2: No spamming. Don’t submit all of your retros at once. Submitting more than 3 at a time will lead to your tracks having a lower chance at being reviewed.
Rule 3: Must be your own tracks: You cannot submit tracks that are stolen, the most common example is the base image being stolen.
Rule 4: Must be complete mode: No quick mode tracks, they’re way to simple I don’t want to give out a ton of low scores.
Rule 5: Follow Forum Rules: This is self explanatory, make sure your track follows forum rules.
Rule 6: Don’t complain: If your track gets a low score, it’s not because I’m purposely hating on you, usually I try to give constructive criticism
to help you improve.
Anyways submit your retros and I’ll rate them.
This is simple, you send me retro tracks and I rate them using a system.
Here are the factors that I will grade on:
Gameplay _/35. This is just does the track play well.
Visual _/25. Does the track look good and fit a style. (Also is the image original and not stolen).
Is it a faithful recreation OR does it add to the original _/30 This depends on if the track is meant to replicate the original, or reimagine it. Depending on which one it is, you will either be graded on how faithful of a recreation it is, or how much it adds to the original while still being the track.
Miscellaneous _/10 This is just general stuff. For example, backgrounds, music, readability.
This leads to a general rating system out of a 100. With the following grading system.
S (99-100)
A (90-98 )
B(80-89)
C(70-79)
D(60-69)
F(0-59)
There are also rules because people always break obvious rules when I fail to establish them.
Rule 1: Must be a retro. The track must be a retro of an official nintendo track, no recreations from other racing games or a remake of your nitros.
Rule 2: No spamming. Don’t submit all of your retros at once. Submitting more than 3 at a time will lead to your tracks having a lower chance at being reviewed.
Rule 3: Must be your own tracks: You cannot submit tracks that are stolen, the most common example is the base image being stolen.
Rule 4: Must be complete mode: No quick mode tracks, they’re way to simple I don’t want to give out a ton of low scores.
Rule 5: Follow Forum Rules: This is self explanatory, make sure your track follows forum rules.
Rule 6: Don’t complain: If your track gets a low score, it’s not because I’m purposely hating on you, usually I try to give constructive criticism
to help you improve.
Anyways submit your retros and I’ll rate them.
If you own Nintendo, what would you do?
On 2026-07-04 at 01:37:14
I would do 3 things.
1. Mario Maker 3. It would add in an NSMBDS theme that would go with the regular themes, as well as add in Mario Wonder as a special theme with wonder flowers as the main gimmick. It would also increase what you could do with super-worlds. It would also have everything necessary
on launch (with QOL updates) which brings me into the next thing.
2. Stop publishing unfinished games. This is simple, all the games from now on would have everything on release (unlike some of the current mario sports games where characters become DLC)
3. Add an option to Mario Kart World where intermission can be turned off online. The lobbies would just be separated to intermission allowed and not allowed.
1. Mario Maker 3. It would add in an NSMBDS theme that would go with the regular themes, as well as add in Mario Wonder as a special theme with wonder flowers as the main gimmick. It would also increase what you could do with super-worlds. It would also have everything necessary
on launch (with QOL updates) which brings me into the next thing.
2. Stop publishing unfinished games. This is simple, all the games from now on would have everything on release (unlike some of the current mario sports games where characters become DLC)
3. Add an option to Mario Kart World where intermission can be turned off online. The lobbies would just be separated to intermission allowed and not allowed.
(1st Anniversary!) Rating Your Circuits from 0-100
On 2026-07-06 at 19:43:19
How about you try a retro track in SsgK now https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=228639
On 2026-07-02 at 21:49:16
1. A new rating topic, where instead of me rating only one track, I will rank Cups! The making of the topic may take a while, but once it’s up and running it will (I hope) be helpful for you!
I like this idea, and I also think that this could be expanded to multicups.
On 2026-07-01 at 03:30:48
I feel like for now one of SsgK’s Nitro’s would be good.https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=228027 Maybe I’ll even do a retro later.
Custom Knockout Tours
On 2026-07-03 at 16:30:56
@Ssg-123, I have your ratings
Carrot Rally
7/10
Notes:
Start in the sky facing north
Left
Straight
Left
Cutoff at the end of the waterfall
Keep going straight
Keep straight to the bridge
Keep straight to the water
Keep straight to the mario kart sign
Left
Go straight continuing the Boomerang Rally path
Alternate path, land or water
Continue the Boomerang Rally path
Keep going forward
Instead of going right then right, go right then left
From there just head to peach stadium
Before the pink road, go right to continue going to Choco Mountain
The next road you see, go there, then left
Keep going straight to the next mario kart sign
From there, just go to Choco Mountain
Split path choco island section
Enter Choco Mountain forward
Keep going forward
Another split path, though when going left dont go left further
Keep going on the path
Go right next
Go right again
Then left
Go through the tunnel to the right
Enter Wario Stadium
Go right
Go to the start line, where the cutoff is
Turn left
Play Wario Stadium
Before the turn before the jump, go to the exit
Play Wario Stadium >>> Shy Guy Bazaar normally, im sure you know it is
Ending in Daisy’s Palace
Propeller Rally
6/10
Notes:
Fall down to Bowser’s Castle and take the ending of the Drill Rally backwards
Enter Dry Bones Burnout backwards
Do Dry Bones Burnout >>> Acorn Heights normally
Once at Acorn Heights, go to the water and keep going straight in water until you reach the end, then turn right to the left most road, that is where the cutoff is
Do Acorn Heights >>> Boo Cinema normally until the ghost valley section
When entering the ghost valley section, go left at the first crossroad
Go until the staircase
Go up the staircase, then make it to the finish line of Boo Cinema, where the cutoff is
At the cutoff, go to the ghost valley
From there, play Boo Cinema >>> Starview peak normally (NOT the Spiny Rally version, in VS race its different) until you get to Starview Peak
At Stariview Peak, the cutoff would be where it is in the Spiny Rally
From there, go to the icy arch formation
Then do the entrance of the Ice Rally backwards
Then obviously play Sky-High Sundae
Bubble Rally
5/10
Notes:
Start gliding down from DK Spaceport, then just do DK Spaceport >>> Crown City normally
At Crown City, go to the starting line at the normal section version, from there, do Crown City >>> Peach Stadium normally
Go to the sideways starting line, where the cutoff is, then go there to Faraway Oasis
Go right at the crossroad
Right again
Straight
Left
Right
Before entering Faraway Oasis, abruptly turn right, where the cutoff is
Right
Straight
Straight again
From there just go to Koopa Troopa Beach
Enter Koopa Troopa Beach forwards, the starting line being the cutoff, from there loop around it do to Koopa Troopa Beach >>> Dino Dino Jungle normally
Normally you do Dino Dino Jungle entering backwards, though here the cutoff would be the turn before entering the track and you’ll turn right to do the track normally
Carrot Rally
7/10
Notes:
Start in the sky facing north
Left
Straight
Left
Cutoff at the end of the waterfall
Keep going straight
Keep straight to the bridge
Keep straight to the water
Keep straight to the mario kart sign
Left
Go straight continuing the Boomerang Rally path
Alternate path, land or water
Continue the Boomerang Rally path
Keep going forward
Instead of going right then right, go right then left
From there just head to peach stadium
Before the pink road, go right to continue going to Choco Mountain
The next road you see, go there, then left
Keep going straight to the next mario kart sign
From there, just go to Choco Mountain
Split path choco island section
Enter Choco Mountain forward
Keep going forward
Another split path, though when going left dont go left further
Keep going on the path
Go right next
Go right again
Then left
Go through the tunnel to the right
Enter Wario Stadium
Go right
Go to the start line, where the cutoff is
Turn left
Play Wario Stadium
Before the turn before the jump, go to the exit
Play Wario Stadium >>> Shy Guy Bazaar normally, im sure you know it is
Ending in Daisy’s Palace
Propeller Rally
6/10
Notes:
Fall down to Bowser’s Castle and take the ending of the Drill Rally backwards
Enter Dry Bones Burnout backwards
Do Dry Bones Burnout >>> Acorn Heights normally
Once at Acorn Heights, go to the water and keep going straight in water until you reach the end, then turn right to the left most road, that is where the cutoff is
Do Acorn Heights >>> Boo Cinema normally until the ghost valley section
When entering the ghost valley section, go left at the first crossroad
Go until the staircase
Go up the staircase, then make it to the finish line of Boo Cinema, where the cutoff is
At the cutoff, go to the ghost valley
From there, play Boo Cinema >>> Starview peak normally (NOT the Spiny Rally version, in VS race its different) until you get to Starview Peak
At Stariview Peak, the cutoff would be where it is in the Spiny Rally
From there, go to the icy arch formation
Then do the entrance of the Ice Rally backwards
Then obviously play Sky-High Sundae
Bubble Rally
5/10
Notes:
Start gliding down from DK Spaceport, then just do DK Spaceport >>> Crown City normally
At Crown City, go to the starting line at the normal section version, from there, do Crown City >>> Peach Stadium normally
Go to the sideways starting line, where the cutoff is, then go there to Faraway Oasis
Go right at the crossroad
Right again
Straight
Left
Right
Before entering Faraway Oasis, abruptly turn right, where the cutoff is
Right
Straight
Straight again
From there just go to Koopa Troopa Beach
Enter Koopa Troopa Beach forwards, the starting line being the cutoff, from there loop around it do to Koopa Troopa Beach >>> Dino Dino Jungle normally
Normally you do Dino Dino Jungle entering backwards, though here the cutoff would be the turn before entering the track and you’ll turn right to do the track normally
For the bubble rally Dino Dino Jungle, the section right before the bridge is the checkpoint. And the you do a full lap of Dino Dino Jungle, continuing to the same checkpoint so that you still do a full lap. Also the numbers in my name are 132, not 123. Oh yeah thanks for the advice!
On 2026-07-03 at 01:41:26
Bowser's Castle - Dry Bones Burnout - Acorn Heights - Boo Cinema - Starview Peak - Sky-High Sundae - Wario Shipyard - Peach Beach - Great ? Block Ruins - Dino Dino Jungle - Koopa Troopa Beach - DK Spaceport - Whistletop Summit - Desert Hills - Shy Guy Bazaar - Airship Fortress - Bowser's Castle
I don’t know if this was intentional, but the first six tracks listed here is an exact copy of my propeller rally, down to the tracks and everything. The next set of six is also really similar to the cherry rally, as well as dk spaceport being really long for an end. I have nothing to say on the third rally. (Sorry if this seems harsh, it’s meant to be constructive criticism.)
Edit: oh I didn’t know it was a full loop.
On 2026-07-02 at 17:28:18
Here’s one of the ideas that I came up with. The Carrot rally (based off of that one super mario land power-up.)
The order is as follows:
Great ? Block ruins -> Faraway oasis -> Cheep Cheep Falls -> Choco Mountain -> Wario Stadium -> Shy Guy Bazaar.
I think that this is a dynamic rally that would take you through several environments. Also this rally would enter into Daisy Palace, which I think is pretty cool.
The other rally that I came up with is the propeller rally (because it starts and ends on a sky track, along with being mostly north)
This route is as follows:
Bowser’s Castle -> Dry Bones Burnout -> Acorn Heights -> Boo Cinema -> Starview peak -> Sky High Sundae.
I think this rally has a really unique concept and ventures through some cool tracks.
And the 3rd rally idea that I had, the Bubble rally (mainly due to the small area of the rally) This rally is as follows
DK Spaceport -> Crown City -> Peach Stadium -> Faraway Oasis -> Koopa Troopa Beach -> Dino Dino Jungle.
I really like the contained area of the rally, and it ends on a unique destination, I think you could also move the checkpoint in DDJ to make the lap complete.
Edit 1: rallies 4-5
The Coin rally: (this is mainly because a lot of these tracks are events that you would pay for, or toads factory where money is made.)
Boo Cinema -> dandelion depths -> mario circuit -> toads factory - dry bones burnout -> wario stadium (this is the reverse version).
I think that this rally would be quite fun with some interesting tracks.
Here is the 5th rally the Blooper Rally (this is because of the heavy usage of water tracks.) Here is the order.
Dandelion Depths -> Cheep Cheep falls -> Wario’s Shipyard -> Peach Beach -> Great ? Block Ruins -> Salty Salty Speedway.
This route actually has the outskirts of Great ? Block Ruins be its checkpoint, mainly to make the last stretch shorter, while still exploring the location
Edit 2: Rally 6
I feel like I spent a lot of effort on this rally. This is the Bob-Omb rally, (no real reason for that title)
We start out the rally in Toad’s Factory, then continue on the Toad’s Factory to Mario Bros Circuit intermission. The first checkpoint is located right before the you truly enter Mario Bros Circuit. The second section has you taking the first turn of Mario Bros Circuit in reverse, and then you take a left turn to continue on the Mario Bros Circuit to Desert Hills intermission. The second checkpoint is located on the Desert Hills starting line. You go through it backwards like usual which sets you up to take the Desert Hills to Shy Guy Bazaar intermission. The third checkpoint is located on the Shy Guy Bazaar starting line. This sets you up to take the Shy Guy Bazaar to Airship Fortress intermission route where the checkpoint is directly below where it usually is, so that you take the area under the track. Lastly we take the Airship Fortress to Dry Bones Burnout intermission. Here we take the side entrance in the usual track, which is also another checkpoint. We then do a full lap on Dry Bones Burnout with the end spot being exactly where it usually is.
Here’s the basic order for this rally:
Toad’s factory -> Mario Bros Circuit -> Desert Hills -> Shy Guy Bazaar -> Airship Fortress intermission route-> Dry Bones Burnout
I think that these are some cool ideas.
If I have any other ideas, I’ll add them.
Oh yeah if anyone could give feedback on these ideas, that would be great!
The order is as follows:
Great ? Block ruins -> Faraway oasis -> Cheep Cheep Falls -> Choco Mountain -> Wario Stadium -> Shy Guy Bazaar.
I think that this is a dynamic rally that would take you through several environments. Also this rally would enter into Daisy Palace, which I think is pretty cool.
The other rally that I came up with is the propeller rally (because it starts and ends on a sky track, along with being mostly north)
This route is as follows:
Bowser’s Castle -> Dry Bones Burnout -> Acorn Heights -> Boo Cinema -> Starview peak -> Sky High Sundae.
I think this rally has a really unique concept and ventures through some cool tracks.
And the 3rd rally idea that I had, the Bubble rally (mainly due to the small area of the rally) This rally is as follows
DK Spaceport -> Crown City -> Peach Stadium -> Faraway Oasis -> Koopa Troopa Beach -> Dino Dino Jungle.
I really like the contained area of the rally, and it ends on a unique destination, I think you could also move the checkpoint in DDJ to make the lap complete.
Edit 1: rallies 4-5
The Coin rally: (this is mainly because a lot of these tracks are events that you would pay for, or toads factory where money is made.)
Boo Cinema -> dandelion depths -> mario circuit -> toads factory - dry bones burnout -> wario stadium (this is the reverse version).
I think that this rally would be quite fun with some interesting tracks.
Here is the 5th rally the Blooper Rally (this is because of the heavy usage of water tracks.) Here is the order.
Dandelion Depths -> Cheep Cheep falls -> Wario’s Shipyard -> Peach Beach -> Great ? Block Ruins -> Salty Salty Speedway.
This route actually has the outskirts of Great ? Block Ruins be its checkpoint, mainly to make the last stretch shorter, while still exploring the location
Edit 2: Rally 6
I feel like I spent a lot of effort on this rally. This is the Bob-Omb rally, (no real reason for that title)
We start out the rally in Toad’s Factory, then continue on the Toad’s Factory to Mario Bros Circuit intermission. The first checkpoint is located right before the you truly enter Mario Bros Circuit. The second section has you taking the first turn of Mario Bros Circuit in reverse, and then you take a left turn to continue on the Mario Bros Circuit to Desert Hills intermission. The second checkpoint is located on the Desert Hills starting line. You go through it backwards like usual which sets you up to take the Desert Hills to Shy Guy Bazaar intermission. The third checkpoint is located on the Shy Guy Bazaar starting line. This sets you up to take the Shy Guy Bazaar to Airship Fortress intermission route where the checkpoint is directly below where it usually is, so that you take the area under the track. Lastly we take the Airship Fortress to Dry Bones Burnout intermission. Here we take the side entrance in the usual track, which is also another checkpoint. We then do a full lap on Dry Bones Burnout with the end spot being exactly where it usually is.
Here’s the basic order for this rally:
Toad’s factory -> Mario Bros Circuit -> Desert Hills -> Shy Guy Bazaar -> Airship Fortress intermission route-> Dry Bones Burnout
I think that these are some cool ideas.
If I have any other ideas, I’ll add them.
Oh yeah if anyone could give feedback on these ideas, that would be great!
I'M HOSTING A TOURNAMENT
On 2026-07-02 at 23:28:07
C
@Ssg-132
B
@MKW_Master_80
A
@M2M0M1M5
@Mablot
@MysticalCow
S
@LuigiXD
@propropro123
S+ [READY]
@COOKING_SON
@CraftoMK07
@X___zxClear___X (me)
@Poofie_Master
TOP I
@Cooking_Papa
@Mr_Manager
@Itari
TOP II
@McDonald
we have only 3 now
@Ssg-132
B
@MKW_Master_80
A
@M2M0M1M5
@Mablot
@MysticalCow
S
@LuigiXD
@propropro123
S+ [READY]
@COOKING_SON
@CraftoMK07
@X___zxClear___X (me)
@Poofie_Master
TOP I
@Cooking_Papa
@Mr_Manager
@Itari
TOP II
@McDonald
we have only 3 now
Please remove me from the competition, I didn't want to join, I just asked a question about how the ranking system is set up.
The more that I think about it. The same thing happened with me (where I asked a question and got signed up) If this happened to two other people, then I would also like to be removed as I don’t know if I can trust somebody who mistakenly signs people up.
On 2026-06-27 at 21:13:51
we need 4 people in each league.
You could always just combine certain ranks to make it easier to get groups. Also I’m in the C rank now.
On 2026-06-24 at 20:42:04
What’s the multicup? I may join in E or D rank.
The multicup hasn't been released yet. I will send the link 7 days after release.
D
@Ssg-132
A
@M2M0M1M5
S
@X___zxClear___X (me)
I’m not signing up yet. I want to see if the multi-cup is actually good.
On 2026-06-24 at 20:08:20
What’s the multicup? I may join in E or D rank.
Your birthday date, your Mario kart world track
On 2026-07-03 at 03:41:54
If you wanted for the tracks dates to make sense. Then I suggest swapping DK Spaceport and Choco Mountain. This way, DK Spaceport is the 25th, which is a reference to 25m.
What are you character and Kart combos in Mario Kart World?
On 2026-06-16 at 04:33:02
Shy Guy has and will always will be my goat. I haven’t played mkworld, but the rally romper looks like it would go great with Shy Guy.
American Countries in the mkpc forum
On 2025-11-08 at 19:39:05
My bad I’m stupid…
Panama
Panama
What is your best MKPC track?
On 2026-06-11 at 22:03:15
Statistically it’s this
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=79980
But this one is my personal favorite
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=127723
Or this, I can’t decide
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=226459
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=79980
But this one is my personal favorite
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=127723
Or this, I can’t decide
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=226459
Track Building Contest : Autumn 2025 / Concours de création de circuits : Automne 2025
On 2025-11-04 at 22:21:51
Cool I might make one.
MKPC News : Showcase your projects, keep us informed about your projects and more !
On 2025-01-07 at 00:48:05
I finally finished the red shell cup in sgk. https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?cid=55643
On 2023-04-19 at 00:44:34
I don’t know what track to create first so i’ll let you dicide the order of the sgk red shell cup right here edit. I changed the poll