Rating Your Circuits from 0-100

Steaming Springs

https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=215477

For context, It's kinda inspired by a hot-tub-spa-hotel my family went to some months back that was built on top of hot springs.

Here is my track:

https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=226045

@https://mkpc.malehieude.net/circuit.php?id=206399

Pipeway Drive
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=226163

Peach's Lake Town, the circuit i made yesterday

https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=201568

There's the link 1st link up there👆

2nd link is down here👇🏼
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=201792

I put so much effort on my brand new track, I hope that youll like it. The map is clickable.

https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=227526 Confusion Concert

did @-Natsuki- forget about this?

tbh? Probably. They haven't answered to this in I don't even know how long.

then chat with @-Natsuki-

or we can pick an alternative judge who is here when the main one isn't.

But who's gonna be the sub judge?

the one who is a true friend to the community

I think im kinda worthy no ?

Idk if they allowed a alt judge

I’m very sorry for everyone who had been waiting for me for days for their tracks to be rated. I was busy doing other things outside this community, that probably lead to confusion of this topic. For my apologies I will be rating all of the tracks that had been posted and not rated yet in this message. (This is my first time rating multiple others in one message, I might do this more often to shorten overflow.)


Track Layout: 25/50
Decor: 13/25
Music: 13/15
Name: 9/10
Bonus: 0/10
Total: 60 (D-/MEME)
This is just probably a CRAPpost (I’m not swearing in this so you know what I’m referring to…), and for @CookieBiscuit or Cookie, the challenges are rated by how many there are, how unique are they and if there rated  3 or more stars. (Which in your case, none of them are rated.)


Track Layout: 40/50
Decor: 21/25
Music: 10/10
Name: 10/10
Bonus: 8/10
Total: 89 (B+)
This idea of the Mario Circuits being combined is great! Though it was a bit laggy…



Track Layout: 43/50
Decor:22/25
Music: 9/10
Name: 8/10
Bonus: 0/10
Total: 82 (B-)
Great City track, and this style of a city track is very unique!


Track Layout: 41/50
Decor: 0/25
Music: 10/10
Name: 9/10
Bonus: 0/10
Total: 60 (D-)
It’s a great track with great gimmicks, the only thing that is missing is the Decorations.


Track Layout: 43/50
Decor: 23/25
Music: 8/10
Name: 9/10
Bonus: 0/10
Total: 83 (B)
Great sky track! I love how the track completely changes at the third section, and I love the atmosphere change!!!


Track Layout: 34/50
Decor:16/25
Music: 9/10
Name: 8/10
Bonus: 0/10
Total: 67 (D+)
This is an interesting take on Bowser’s castle. It’s really bland though.


Track Layout: 42/50
Decor: 17/25
Music: 13/15
Name: 10/10
Bonus: 0/10
Total: 82 (B-)
I’ve never visualized an hot spring track but this is incredible!


Track Layout: 26/50
Decor: 2/25
Music: 7/15
Name: 9/10
Bonus: 0/10
Total: 44 (F)
This track lacks the variety of Decor and the track is ok but it is a little bit blurry.


Sorry, I can’t rate this if the url doesn’t lead to an actual page…, if necessary please send the link again.


Track Layout: 44/50
Decor: 15/25
Music: 8/10
Name: 8/10
Bonus:5/10
Total: 80 (B-)
I love the visuals of this track but the decoration is a bit lacking. The description is cool too, I guess.


Track Layout: 39/50
Decor: 18/25
Music: 11/15
Name: 8/10
Bonus: 0/10
Total: 76 (C)
This is a good track, however the track is a little repetitive.


If you’re a bit new to this topic this is for you: whenever you post multiple circuits, they will all be rated under one grade. I will put the best track up on display too.
Track Layout: 33/50
Decor: 7/25
Music: 8/15
Name: 9/10
Bonus: 0/10
Total: 57 (F)
While the layout itself isn’t that bad, the decoration is heavily lacking.
Best: DS Desert Hills

Track Layout: 49/50
Decor: 25/25
Music: 13/15
Name:10/10
Bonus:10/10
Total: 107 (S+)
This track is wonderful! I really love the flow of the track, the theme of it and the music all blends together! This is by far one of the best tracks I’ve ever seen!




Once again, I am very sorry for the 2 weeks of inactivity on this topic. All of your tracks were beautiful in their own way. I don’t want you to be upset about these points, I’ve created this topic because I wanted people to improve their skills with track building, acknowledgement in good tracks, and most importantly, the fairness of the ratings. I’ve chosen myself to do all of these three things, and I don’t really know if I’m succeeding or not, because I don’t personally know you all. And, if I feel that I need anyone to assist me in this goal: to make MKPC a better place, then I will choose someone who I trust dearly to help lead this topic when I’m not here. Thank you all for your support for this topic, I really thought this would be dead in 5 days of making the topic, but I was wrong… this topic has aged very well, I don’t want it to die now. So I promise you all that I will be active on July… and if I’m not, then I’m sorry in advance.

I feel like for now one of SsgK’s Nitro’s would be good.https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=228027 Maybe I’ll even do a retro later.