[Original] Rating Your Circuits from 0-100

[Version 3.0]

This is a simplified topic of Rating Your Complete Mode Multicups From 0-100 (It’s dead now. I will be making a new topic the same as this soon.) but it is a lot easier to share them out to me so I can rate it. On to the main stuff!

Rules:

1. Use Complete mode. (Quick mode tracks are mostly almost the same, so it is almost impossible to rate them. And the Creativity is usually at a minimal level.)

2. Do Not Steal Anyone Else's Tracks! (This is a self explanted rule as breaking it also violates the MKPC TOS. My team will be reporting stolen tracks if we see them.)

3. Please give me the link to the track and the name to the track. (it should be highlighted in orange when you do it. EX:
Rin’s Sanctuary of Gardens https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=217170
or
Rin’s Sanctuary of Gardens
(Use the url feature in the BB code section if you don't know what I'm talking about))

4. Don't rush (Take your time don't rush, as doing that may result in lower scores.)

5. We will do our best to be honest about the scores. (That doesn’t mean I wasn’t in the past, this is to say that this is not bias in any way so don’t be offended please.)

Ratings/Grades:

Minimum: 5 Maximum: 110

(100-110)S: One of the best tracks I've ever seen
(90-99)A+ through A- : Great track
(80-89)B+ through B- : Good track
(70-79)C+ through C- : Neutral track
(60-69)D+ through D- : Average Track
(0-59)F : Poor Track
(0-110)MEME : Meme track
(NEW) (0/110) KAIZO : Kaizo Track

Grading: (110 points in total.)

Track layout 50 points (Use your own track designs.(Further explanation is that the layout has to be unique and fun to drive around for it to get a high score.) Retros are acceptable but please make it stand out from the original. If the track represents a bland geometric layout it will always score a 5.)

Decor 25 points (Use Decorations at reasonable spots. Points are also determined on how many there are and if they’re necessary. If there are none it will be marked as 0/25)

Music 15 points (use reasonable music for the track. (If I can’t hear it, I will always go to the Music Link so don’t worry. I don’t know if the others will do that as well) If there is no music 9 times out of 10 it will be rated a 0/15)

Name 10 points (use a reasonable name to the track. Naming a Track that doesn’t make complete sense to the track itself will always Score a 5. (If untitled it will receive 0/10) Retro Tracks that Don’t Have the Prefix will not get full credit EX: DS Airship Fortress✔️, Wario’s Galleon❌, they will instead get a 7 if not Prefixed)

[Bonus] Challenges: 10 points (will be given out if the circuit has verified challenges, (the best (the most rated) challenge has to be verified and has to have at least 2.5 stars  rated by raters who attempted/beat it as well to get a minimum of 5 points ([New]:for harder challenges, we will attempt to give the best shot at these challenges))

[NEW] Rater Role: Rating tracks is a lot to handle for one person, so I will now be giving you all the power to rate tracks (under my verification though). So here are the separate rules about this role:

•You have to really understand how the rating criteria works. But don’t worry, mistakes happen sometimes, but I won’t be the end of the world if it happens.

•If a track is unable to be rated (either because its not fully finished or it is a Quick Mode track) POLITELY reject to rate it, never spread negativity on this topic (or even on this site.)

•When playing the tracks, make sure to check if you are on 150cc (since that is the standard CC class for Mario Kart) and make sure that you are on Time Trials and saving your ghost is optional.

•When manually giving out bonus points, please give the amount of stars that you would give to the challenge.
2.5*: 5 points
3*: 6 points
3.5*: 7 points
4*: 8 points
4.5*: 9 points
5*: 10 points
Anything under is 0 points

Violate any of the rules below and you will get 2 strikes before temporary demotion or permanent demotion.

•Do not unrealistically rate a track <5/100 or >110+/100. First reason, that’s impossible for it to happen due to the grading rules. And second, most likely it could be trolling or something far worse. So please don’t do it. (Punishment may vary depending on the reason)

•Self-explanatory, do not be negative with other players. (Punishment could be a 1 week demotion)

•Do not rate any type of inappropriate tracks, as you could be contributing to the TOS violation. (Punishment is a 1 day demotion)

• Do not abuse this power to self rate your tracks, this of course isn’t possible for the Star Rating that this site actually uses, so it applies here too. (Punishment is a permanent demotion)

This is the end of the Violation rules, I will be adding more to the list soon, but this is for starters. Also I will note, if you are banned on this site you will be demoted until your ban is removed from your account.

The Circuit Rater List:
-Rin- (Captain)




We will be waiting

https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=176750
Yup, Mario Bros. Circuit.

Track Layout:25/50
Decor:7/25
Music:11/15
Name:10/10
Bonus0/10
Total:53 (F)
Make sure you follow step 4 again next time, but still a decent track

Track Layout:48/50
Decor:25/25
Music:15/15
Name:10/10
Bonus:0/10
Total: 98 (A+)
The track is super fun but some parts of the tracks can throw off new players or players who use RD

Track Layout:30/50
Decor:0/25
Music:10/15
Name:8/10
Bonus:0/10
Total:48 (F)
Cool gimmick but use it for shortcuts than just a death trap.

https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?cid=61546

Sorry, I'm sending you a whole cup so that you can rank 4 of my custom tracks.

P.S. I accidentally made the courses perfect for 50cc so pls play on 50cc!

Thanks for playing!

Track layout:20/50
Decor:20/25
Music:10/15
Name:8/10
Bonus:9.5/10
Total 67.5 (D+)
The only thing thats the problem is that the track is a little bit small

Track Layout:40/50
Decor:22/25
Music:10/15
Name:9/10
Bonus:0/10
Total: 81 (B-)
The shift of the backgrounds are pretty good imo and is good for TT (Time Trailing)

I'm just going to combine all 4 in to one rating because they're pretty much the same.

Track Layout:15/50
Decor:3/25
Music:10/15
Name:6/10
Bonus:0/10
Total: 34 (F)
I can tell that you're new to this community (so welcome to the MKPC Community) please follow rule No4 next time
Best Circuit: Crown City

here's one
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=185771
its based off an area from Super metroid

Track Layout:15/50
Decor:10/25
Music:10/15
Name:7/10
Total 52 (F)
Please follow rule No4 Next time

https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=173428
This isn’t against the rules, it has lap overrides. This has taken so long, trust me. Especially on Pixilart, it takes a lot.

Track Layout:30/50
Decors:15/25
Music:10/15
Name:8/10
Bonus:8/10
Total: 71 (C-)
The track is too big but the override is very impactful to the last lap

Mario Circuit 9
I've made it within Minecraft.

Track Layout:35/50
Decor:15/25
Music:10/15
Name:9/10
Bonus:0/10
Total: 69 (D)
Good track, it might need a little bit more decors

I didt rush the track though.
eh, i did good on most stuff. I guess the layout is just kind of average.