/| Mario Kart PC |\

Rating Your Circuits from 0-100

smile

Page:  ...  10 

Messages 187 - Bowser Bowser
vs19272 pts ★ Master
battle5228 pts ★ Novice
Croatia
Koopa Circuit
A map i made 2-3 days ago
Messages 35 - Koopa Koopa
vs7450 pts ★ Racer
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
France
Koopa Circuit
A map i made 2-3 days ago

Hello, it is a good track, 85/100
Suggestion : Improve the design of boosts
Messages 81 - Boo Boo
vs5531 pts ★ Novice
battle4930 pts ★ Budding pilot
Ireland
Markio15 wrote:
Koopa Circuit
A map i made 2-3 days ago

Hello, it is a good track, 85/100
Suggestion : Improve the design of boosts

It's ok. Give it 68/100. The music is fine
Messages 404 - Metal Luigi Metal Luigi
vs20194 pts ★ Legend
battle6855 pts ★ Racer
United States
Koopa Circuit
A map i made 2-3 days ago


Track Layout: 42/50
Decor: 13/25
Music: 11/15
Name: 8/10
Bonus: 0/10
Total: 74 (C)

The tracks layout is fun, and it’s also useful that you traced the ideal racing line for beginners! Although it lacks heavy in the decoration.

Also I have to mention this, others grading others is fine. But it doesn’t affect my scoring of tracks.
Messages 404 - Metal Luigi Metal Luigi
vs20194 pts ★ Legend
battle6855 pts ★ Racer
United States
Giller wrote:
-Natsuki- wrote:
Giller wrote:
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=221340

I think this will score in the F tier
Challenges will come soon

Track Layout: 25/50
Decor: 5/25
Music: 12/15
Name: 5/10
Bonus: 0/10 (Will potentially be updated)
Total: 47 (F)

The layout is both confusing and some parts are too thin, and it’s pretty easy to make errors and fall off. And adding more decor would also be a great solution to the visuals of the track.

A question did I really need to put SMO New Donk City instead of New Donk City because I couldnt do anything else to gain point from the title of my track? And did the final lap music lose me points? And have you played Super Mario Odyssey?
Sorry if I been too negative there Super Mario Odyssey was my first mainline Mario game and Donkey Kong Bananza is my favourite game and both of them have NDC in them.

And not related to NDC I might make a hand drawn map. But I think you rate it a lot lower than this one.
Thanks
First question’s answer is a no. Second question’s answer is no, but instead both of them affected the music score. Third question’s answer is no, but I have seen almost every part of New Donk City; the problem is the lack of color. And I’m not a huge Mario fan, so I won’t criticize you in anyway. You’re Welcome! hap
Messages 540 - Mario Mario
vs16150 pts ★ Master
battle9813 pts ★ Expert
Canada
Axolotl Park

I am very proud of this track!
Messages 81 - Boo Boo
vs5531 pts ★ Novice
battle4930 pts ★ Budding pilot
Ireland
-Natsuki- wrote:
Giller wrote:
-Natsuki- wrote:
Giller wrote:
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=221340

I think this will score in the F tier
Challenges will come soon

Track Layout: 25/50
Decor: 5/25
Music: 12/15
Name: 5/10
Bonus: 0/10 (Will potentially be updated)
Total: 47 (F)

The layout is both confusing and some parts are too thin, and it’s pretty easy to make errors and fall off. And adding more decor would also be a great solution to the visuals of the track.

A question did I really need to put SMO New Donk City instead of New Donk City because I couldnt do anything else to gain point from the title of my track? And did the final lap music lose me points? And have you played Super Mario Odyssey?
Sorry if I been too negative there Super Mario Odyssey was my first mainline Mario game and Donkey Kong Bananza is my favourite game and both of them have NDC in them.

And not related to NDC I might make a hand drawn map. But I think you rate it a lot lower than this one.
Thanks
First question’s answer is a no. Second question’s answer is no, but instead both of them affected the music score. Third question’s answer is no, but I have seen almost every part of New Donk City; the problem is the lack of color. And I’m not a huge Mario fan, so I won’t criticize you in anyway. You’re Welcome! hap

Well atleast I tried. And yes I will admit the colours of bad but I don't think I could of done anything to make it better. But 47/100 is better than 46/100 so I guess I could of got a worse rating overall. But I might make a handdrawn map next time.
Messages 35 - Koopa Koopa
vs7450 pts ★ Racer
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
France
It is my first track, so pardon me if there are bad. The track are a quite hard : https://mkpc.malahieude.net/circuit.php?id=229719
Messages 105 - Buzzy Beetle Buzzy Beetle
vs12776 pts ★ Champion
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
United States
Mario Kart World Bowser's Castle
this is probably my best track, I played over the three races I know aren't bad and this one's the only one I actually like. I will admit it's a bit disorienting at first but when you look at the map it makes more sense.
Messages 81 - Boo Boo
vs5531 pts ★ Novice
battle4930 pts ★ Budding pilot
Ireland
Markio15 wrote:
It is my first track, so pardon me if there are bad. The track are a quite hard : https://mkpc.malahieude.net/circuit.php?id=229719

81/100 Fun
101/100 Difficult
Messages 35 - Koopa Koopa
vs7450 pts ★ Racer
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
France
El_Gileto wrote:
Markio15 wrote:
It is my first track, so pardon me if there are bad. The track are a quite hard : https://mkpc.malahieude.net/circuit.php?id=229719

81/100 Fun
101/100 Difficult

Yes, a quite difficult, I have made a Trial, where you have to finish the track under 2:45. Thanks for your review.

Page:  ...  10 

Back to International forum
Back to the forum