"I'll rate your MKPC tracks" returns!

BEFORE POSTING TRACKS ON HERE PLEASE READ ENTIRE MESSAGE.
If you aren't posting or already have posted you can scroll down to see the current ranking.

Hi, if you didn't know, I am Neowave.

A while back I had a topic called "I'll rate your Mario Kart PC tracks".

People would send me links to their best tracks and I would rate them on a scale of 1-30.
Here's how I would rate them:

Layout: 1-10
Visuals: 1-10
Fun: 1-10

After that I would add up the total scores of the track, (for example, if one had a 7/10 layout, 9/10 visuals, and 7/10 fun, it's final score would be 7+7+9 which is 23.)

If a track got 24 or higher it would be on my list of most recommended tracks, which turned out to be confusing and people had mixed feelings on the final list.

BUT NOW, THE TOPIC HAS RETURNED.
This time I will have a list of 20 tracks*. Each time someone posts a track on here, I will put it on the list of 1-50th place.

So for example, the first track posted on here will be #1, because it has no competition. But as soon as another track comes along, I will see if it's better or worse than the track previously posted. If worse, it will go to #2. If better, it will go to #1 and the previous track will become #2. Makes sense? Hopefully.

I will still be using the same formula as the last post (layout, visuals, fun) to rate it.

Anyway the list will be done as soon as I get 50 tracks OR it becomes October 5th.

Once the list is done, the top 5 people get followed by me.

RULES FOR POSTING TRACKS:

I accept Quick Mode AND Complete Mode

You may not post more than 3 tracks. Or else the list could be filled up with just one person's tracks.

You may not rate people's tracks while on this site. Only I will be rating the track, unless certain occasions where I may let people help me decided if a track is better.

You may not post tracks that have already been posted on my previous topic.

*Top 50 tracks posted on this topic:

1. GK Prohibited Site by @Cooking_Papa Score: 28
2. Retro Maze 2 by @JoseDaGaming Score: 26
3. N64 Rainbow Road by @BlueCore Score: 26
4. Forest Grounds by @Mikutown Score: 25
5. Pac-Man World Rally - Retro Maze by @JoseDaGaming Score: 25
6. Tidal Island Beach by @Mikutown Score: 23
7. Choco Island 2 by @BlueCore Score: 23
8. Mesmerizer Circuit by @Onlycustometracks Score: 22
9. Miku's Musical Electrodrome by @Mikutown Score: 20
10. Pac-Man Kart World Rally by @JoseDaGaming Score 19
11. Vanilla Milkshake by @BlueCore Score: 18


Link to my previous topic "I'll rate your Mario Kart PC tracks": https://mkpc.malahieude.net/topic.php?topic=20572

https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=150767
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=233153
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=124936

Tidal Island Beach:

Layout: 7: A circle layout, but with good turns and use of split paths

Visuals: 8: Nice use of decor, and beautiful sand and rock coloring.

Fun: 8: Great track, feels good to drive on.

23/30

Forest Grounds:

Layout: 8: Great use of turns and jumps.

Visuals: 9: Driving on the river felt really cool, and the goombas and Cheep Cheep make this track feel even more wild.

Fun: 8: Again, a great track.

25/30

Miku's Musical Electrodome:

Layout: 6: Not as many turns, but good for snaking.

Visuals: 7: The Super Star thwomps go good with this track, and the neon colors are cool.

Fun: 7: Pretty fun, the guitar part is cool, but some parts feel slow.

20/30

remember, I accept quick mode AND complete mode tracks.

Alright Then, Lets See If Ive Improved...

Pac-Man World Rally - Retro Maze (Redone Visuals)
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=220622

Retro Maze 2 - (Custom)
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=230430

Pac-Man Kart Rally
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=232946

Pac-Man World Rally - Retro Maze:

Layout: 7: Cool and nostalgic, but it can get a little confusing especially with the shortcuts.

Visuals: 10: WOW. I love how PAC man is looking over all the racers in the background, and it looks straight out of the game.

Fun: 8: Fun turns items, and overall very enjoyable. Only thing is it's kinda long and could be a section track or 1-2 lap track.

Score is 25/30

Retro Maze 2:

Layout: 7: Had the same feelings as the first one.

Visuals: 10: Love the red color, and also very great like the first one.

Fun: 9: Again, a lot like the first one, but I really like the teleporters on the edges.

26/30

Pac-Man Kart Rally:

Layout: 7: Good idea, the green section was my favorite.

Visuals: 8: Nice visuals, good use of decor.

Fun: 4: Unfortunetly, it wasn't that fun. Pretty flat, and very long.

19/25

Mesmerizer circuithttps://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=234071pls rate

Hi, please rate this:

GK Prohibited site

GK is Garfield Kart if you're wondering

N64 Rainbow Road

Layout: 9: Adds some new cannons, but still very faithful to the og.

Visuals: 9: I like this color scheme you use. In fact, I actually like it better than what 8dlx did.

Fun: 8: Pleasing to drive on and look at, but it was really long.

Total is 26/30

Choco Island 2:

Layout: 8: I mean, it's Choco island 2, it's got some fun turns and I like how you added jumps through that wide part.

Visuals: 7: Not much going on here besides the trees, but still good.

Fun: 8: Generally fun, had some fun turns to drift on, and was fast paced, which is nice compared to the rainbow road.

Total is 23/30

Vanilla Milkshake:

Layout: 5: Mostly straight, and the teleporters kinda feels weird in this track.

Visuals: 7: I like the vanilla trees and goombas, but not much else is here.

Fun: 6: It was alright. Had some fun, but also was kinda boring.

Total is 18/30

note: if I rate your track, it wont show up on the 1-50 ranking immediately. sometimes I wait to get other people's tracks so I can do it all at once

Layout: 8: Had some good turns and boosts, and the decoration is nice, but I feel like there are too many of those spiky yellow things (sorry I don't know what those are)

Visuals: 7: I have no idea how Miku and Teto got here but they did. I like the swirly version of the pendulum though!

Fun: 7: Fun to race on, but over decorated.

Total score is 22/30

Layout: 9: Had really fun turns, and even some good places for snaking! Small but only problem is that the cannons could've been jumps but other than that very solid layout!

Visuals: 10: Really like the bulldozers. Also the whole vibe of the track. It just looks awesome.

Fun: 9: Really enjoyed this one. Just like caskou part, it was just the right length for 3 laps.

Total is 28/30

Yellow things are stars 13 wings

GBA Bowser Castle 2 (Remake)

https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=233438

I sent my 3 best tracks on the previous topic I think so I'll just send SNES Mario Circuit 2 for now

Link: https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=229471

WII U mario kart stadium(my version)https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=234109

sorry I'm only doing tracks

Layout: 8: Faithful to the original, with fun turns and jumps.

Visuals: 9: Really like the lava bubble and thwomps sprites. The whole track itself looks good too.

Fun: 8: Great track, great fun.

Total is 25/30